Even if one could get past all of the greed, the commercialism, consumerism that is typ
ical of a multi-media conglomerate, what about what the movies themselves promote? In the article written by Henry Giroux entitled, “Are Disney Movies Good For Your Kids?”, Giroux writes, “Even more disturbing is the widespread belief that Disney’s trademarked innocence renders it unaccountable for the diverse ways in which is shapes the sense of reality it provides for children as they take up particular and often sanitized notions of identity, culture, and history in the seemingly apolitical cultural universe of the Magic Kingdom.” You could pick out almost any animated Disney movie and find very similar plot lines and strangely enough, this repetitive plot never really seems to deviate from the assigned gender roles that have emerged as the norm in Disney films. In the movie Snow White, our female lead is saved first by the hunter who warns her against harm. Fleeing from her “wicked stepmother” Snow White befriends the seven dwarves and sticks around to cook and clean for them, taking on the obvious role of home-maker/ house-wife in exchange for staying there. So while the dwarves leave to work in the mines each day, Snow White stays at home, baking and cleaning etc. Hmmm. Every portrayal of Snow White in this movie reeks of stereotypical female classification. Even the sound of Snow White’s voice when she speaks. It’s exceedingly high pitched, she sounds very timid yet sweet and her vocabulary is brimming with exclamations of “oh!” and “oh my!” You know what I mean. The lyrics to the theme song in Snow White are as follows, “Someday my prince will come, someday we'll meet again, and away to his castle we'll go to be happy forever I know… And wedding bells will ring, some day when my dreams come true.”http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0niwn2pOEno
I ask you, what does this say to young, impressionable girls??? You’re incomplete until you find Prince Charming? You’re going to be unhappy until he sweeps you off your feet and takes you away to his castle? Who knows. Don’t get me wrong, I was raised watching the old school Disney movies, back when they were good, and they will always have a special place in my heart. But reading this article has really made me examine what kind of positive influence (if any) these movies are having on the youth of today.
There's a pretty cool book that you might like, although it's a little dated now: Kiss Sleeping Beauty Good-Bye, by Madonna Kolbenschlag. It's a somewhat foundational book in feminist criticism of fairy tales, and although it's not specifically about Disney movies, the criticism applies, since Disney has mined traditional fairy tales for so many of its animated blockbusters.
ReplyDeleteQuestion, though: What makes Disney "filthy" in your estimation? Is it that all large corporations are filthy, or is Disney particularly corrupt for some reason?